So, apparently green roofs will burn. (Here's a video of a green roof on fire, from the wonderful Green Building Law Update.)
This makes a lot of sense - I know someone who let a trash burning take over a meadow, so why would an artificial meadow be different?
What concerns me more is:
1) How resistant to heat/damage are the underlying parts of the assembly, which seem to feature plastics?
2) What does one do to the owner's insurance rates when one chooses a green roof?
3) How do the firefighters feel about their ability to do their job when a green-roofed building is on fire...I've heard that some firefighters don't like metal roofs, as they're harder to get through to access a burning attic. Even though the insurance rates are lower, for metal roofs.
I'm sure more data will come to light on this notion soon.
There are no concerns with green roofs when done right!
Germany has over 1 billion square feet of new green roof construction every year - since more than 20 years. There is no fire reported!
As said - when done right - regarding materials, plant selection and use of green roof.
I wouldn't say tray systems - as seen in the movie - are the best solution against fire hazards but it is a good start.
I understand that America is concerned because America is behind most environmental technologies or often tries to reinvent the wheel.
jbi
Posted by: Jorg Breuning | September 17, 2009 at 12:01 AM
Wait, green roofs had been in used in Norway for centuries and I'd never heard of an incident involving fire because of these roofs. Green roofs are also a growing trend in Japan because of the lack of space for gardens. I think yeah, if properly done, green roofs are definitely safe.
Posted by: Rodney Orton | June 01, 2011 at 01:56 PM
Would an access door to the attic solve the problem with metal roofs? What can you suggest to the homeowners who already have metal roofs for their houses?
Posted by: Galliena Gornet | July 29, 2011 at 01:10 PM